we can hold the concept in mind while we construct an answer that communicates our rootedness in multiple places. One of the questions I dread most is a seemingly innocent one: where are you from? The combination of universities and tech companies draws people to the state from all over the world. If you donate just a coffee, lunch or whatever you can today, TRY3STEPS could keep thriving. we can hold the concept in mind while we construct an answer that communicates our rootedness in multiple places. This simple question can comprehend so many different concepts depending upon who is asking, why they are asking, and where you, the respondent, happen to be emotionally and physically when you are answering. Kathy. Be proud of your etches, life painting and the journey that you’re on. Upgrade to a paid plan to monitor for new ways that people talk & ask questions about your brand, product or topic. ( Log Out / Updated 2 hours ago: Lol, why Bazza. Sorry – but in my experience, I do not find the question intimidating in the least. Everything that is absolute, strict, framed, labeled already belongs to past the time you mention it. Good answers! Like you, I tend to be more sensitive towards the question no matter how many times I’ve been asked it. After seeing the pic at the top of your post and reading ” Each pair of shoes travels far and wide”, I thought for sure you were going to say, “I’m from everywhere my shoes have taken me”! So sorry for you and sad people actually have another opinion of you entirely after you’ve answered the question. There is no one correct answer. This Simple Question Can Be Complicated to Answer. I was intrigued by the fact we were deep on the coast of Maine, where we were vacationing from England, only to see this amazing Maine antique shop flying the UK flag. # 8 is genius! If you continue to use this site we will assume that you are happy with it. Home is what we make it to be. Alice is a US citizen, born and raised in the US. The person who asked the question seemed quite miffed at that response, and you are right in saying that not all responses will go down well with everyone and in each context. Jim. The question “Where are you from?” can have a lot of emotional, psychological and personal weight on it. - Countries and nationalities - Short dialogues to act out Level: elementary Age: 8-11 Downloads: 630 For example, what makes someone Australian? The video Matthew posted is hilarious!!! How to answer “Where are you from?” is entirely up to you. I either state all 5 countries which I absolutely hate! So true what you said – not all of us will have ties with a certain place even if our parents do. Sometimes the different parts of us, our looks, the way we speak and our story make people so confused. Just because I’ve got a foreign mother mean I’m an expert on that country. You ever ask a Caucasian Australian with a noticeable accent where he/she is from? (Which is also kind of not clear, but oh well, better than explaining where I’m from. And all that returning and talking in past tense etc. At the end of the day, I don’t know which is more amusing when people first meet me: them asking me “Where are you from?” or them stereotypically assuming I hail from Asia based on my accent and looks. Answer Save. Whether you're an immigrant, a nomad, a third culture kid, or a cosmopolitan at home on the internet, having to answer where one is from can be a loaded experience for many. But we were relating, finding things in common, sharing a passion and our story. This option usually happens by accident because I sometimes panic if I’m not ready for the question as stupid as it sounds! On that same drive to my parents after leaving the beach, we drove past an antique shop flying the Union Jack flag. Change ), You are commenting using your Facebook account. My response depends on my mood and the tone of the person throwing this phrase at me. They are usually wrong. Where I grew up? No roads. Australia is a migrant country, so you would think that a lot of Aussie citizens/ancestors are from diverse background and/or countries. I have a sister who lives in Tasmania. Interestingly I have the European version of the film which has the better front cover on it. Here’s how that conversation might go: Lv 7. They help to build confidence in writing spanish. 5 months ago. But if you have a positive attitude, well, this question will always be a fun one , I’ve also been asked this question quite a few times but sometimes I feel uncomfortable with answering it. First I answer which town I live in, which is met with “No, where are you from originally?” to which I reply which country I grew up in i.e. Then again, it’s a question that can help make connections. Cheers. Favourite answer… I also agree avoiding the question is usually the worst option. “Great!” “I’m doing really well, thank you,” or “Fantastic!” are all good ways to answer. I don’t mind being asked it most of the time, but it’s only when it’s asked very suddenly out of the blue. WHERE ARE YOU FROM- Countries and Nationalities+ Pronouns+ 2 PAGES Level: elementary Age: 6-17 Downloads: 419 : Quiz for 4th grade pupils Level: elementary Age: 5-12 Downloads: 381 : With this response, an audible uncomfortable pause follows and a rush of awkwardness simmers between me and the person who asked the question. The question is always more than meets the eye, and often the person asking it has a pre-defined notion of who we *should* me. Where my ancestors come from? As an Asian Australian who speaks with a slightly tinged Singaporean-Malaysian accent, quite often here in Melbourne people ask me when we’re mid-conversation, “Where are you from?”. - A guy asked me while we were in Bangkok. The differences will become clear later on, I hope. Fine, thanks. 1) I don’t like to be framed or put a label on me. That may come true one day. , Australia is where I found my independence, love for travel, and the courage to try something my family never thought I was capable of doing on my own. And live here still. I’ve been mistaken for “mixed race” all my life and often received questions such as “which one of your parents is white?” & “So, have you & your sister got different dad’s” which is quite uncomfortable, rude and insensitive (we are full blood sisters). Tip 2: If you feel uncomfortable answering, politely respond with a question of your own to avoid giving a direct response. If you get them all correct, you can be my friend. Sign in. Grew up in Australia, have an Aussie accent, and have viewpoints which are considered ‘non-Asian’. Lv 7. Thank you for the response. So far, I’ve responded with these statements and here are the reactions I get: This is very true. You can sign in to give your opinion on the answer. I haven’t seen one like this before that addresses the topic straight on. Kathy. I have been in Bankok my whole life. Anna: Hello! It's not illegal for firemen to refuse to go in if the fire was criminal. But my parents are Malaysian. Accept Read More. Thanks for sharing this video Matt! State the 5 countries according to my mum & dad’s side e.g. When asked, I answer the truth: “I’m a Pakistani Frog who lives in Mexico”. My friends in Australia do consider me as Australian, though some randoms on the street will sometimes ask, “Where are you from”, with one man referring to me as a tourist once when I was riding a bus in Sydney. Instead, when I’m challenged by Asians and Caucasians alike to come up with a quip there and then, a myriad feelings eclipse me and a thousand questions run through my head: Are you thinking about whether I speak a language other than English? “Where are you from?” is an OK question, and I do love to answer it. Where are you from? And since I feel like the Netherlands is my second home, I find it’s bit confusing to answer the question, so I always reply as “It’s complicated, I have two home countries.” I’ve been working on another blog post about this question again for a while now. I guess I need to ask that question back at people more. There…….. Such a good post Mabel! You grew up here.”. But when translated to English, instead of saying “Where is your origin,” this phrase is translated to “Where are you from?”. If so, I'm fully authorized to live and work in the U.S. Jessica Dolcourt. It really depends on who asks the question, and if you want to deliver the long or short answer. And it’s not like I completely took all the cultural features but shared some of them. Lv 6. The thing is: Like you, I get confused when white Australians or Asian Australians ask me “Where are you from?”. Our ancestors all come from somewhere, usually a different city or country altogether. To the question, I responded, “That is completely irrelevant”. How specific you need to be depends on who is asking. Here's everything you need to know. I’d rather people mind their own business. I also finds that this sort of “breaks down” the list of countries and doesn’t sound so excessive (It probably does but not as much as option 1) The caption ‘Each pair of shoes travels far and wide. I typically understand people are just curious , but I also felt annoyed sometimes. Once I had someone who kept insisting that I was from New Zealand, but this is another story altogether , When I was living in Taiwan, an American from California asked where I was from. These days I don’t mind the question at all…I love seeing people’s reactions and in a sense it’s a way to see who has a good sense of humour. Even if we don’t want to answer the “Where are you from?” question with “I grew in Nigerien, French, English, American and mission ‘soil'” (!) 5 months ago. I’m not from here.” And then he immediately objected. Why are you interested in me? I have been in Bangkok since my birth. I guess that means I’m a bad American. I do feel (and I hope it doesn’t offend anyone who may read this) that we do live in a white culture, in the sense that generally speaking most people won’t ask a white person where they’re from, unless perhaps if they have a different accent. Usually, they catch on to my humorous side and gamely play along. Also, they are those whom I’ve met not too long ago and perceive as strangers. No one likes having to answer the same question over and over and over again. This is where I have 3 options: How to answer “Where are you from?” is entirely up to you. Despite its brevity, “Where are you from?” can be a loaded question. Not to mention I was constantly abused during that whole time, being berated and told that I was not good enough to do anything in life, as well as being told that I was delusional for thinking I knew what I wanted. However, the majority of the time this answer doesn’t work with people of Black origin & other ethnicities, they like to know EXACTLY what country you’re from. Cross-cultural children, in particular, struggle with that question. That is so interesting to hear you’re a halfie, and proud of it! Yes Although I’m not Asian I could in part relate to the story behind ‘Shanghai Kiss’. I’ll post here once I’ll have something if you don’t mind. No one has won yet and I have few friends. More often than not, I feel it is too much of an effort to do just that, and will just mumble something about my parents’ home country – and the other person will immediately ‘get it’. Those answers will bore the examiner to death and lower your vocabulary and fluency scores. For these people, a valid answer could include “Heaven on Earth”. Which answer is the I'm devoted to help you move and create a life you love, wherever you are. To me, your background is very interesting. It does confuse me sometimes when people ask that I guess the ‘where are you from’ question’s preferred answer depends on each individual. No one likes having to answer the same question over and over and over again. I’m French, born and raised abroad. And that amount of time certainly warrants claiming it as a place to be from. But it really is fun sometimes to get people to guess my heritage and race when it pops up! Later I took some from Indian, native American, Finnish, Chinese while continued to have the interest in Japanese and Hawaiian. “fairly innocent” is a good way of putting it. This is a more friendly-sounding answer than "fine". Also includes the names of countries in Hindi. 2. Take care Mabel. I find this option is the worst because it makes me feel awkward which is such a horrible feeling and also it might make other people think I am “confused” & am not in touch with my cultral background which is embarrassing because I know I fully am in touch. So it was like going “home”. Though you should have your answer relate to the job, it's also important to share what you want in a career. on both sides I have Portuguese, Guyanese, then on my mum’s side I have Brazilian and Trinidadian and my dad’s side Jamaican. For ex. Sometimes if you pick the wrong one it creates some extra weirdness. I have been in Bankok my whole life. This one – “Where are you from?” – comes up all the time. Sign in. Which answer is the If I was born in Louisiana on March 1st and lived in Dallas from March 3rd until I'm 30 then the answer is Louisiana. Where are you from? xD hahaha…, Hahaha! The North, the South, midwest, etc. You could hardly tell where i am from… based on my (English) accent… then i landed in NZ with PR. I am Australian. I like adding a dash of humour to my responses when answering “Where are you from?”. Anyway, of course I was forced to live elsewhere completely against my will. I’m sure you don’t get the question all the time, if at all. If this sounds familiar to you, then you totally understand why “Where are you from?” is so complicated but also why you might have a different answer depending upon where you are when you’re asked the question. 10 Embracing Change Quotes To Fix A Negative... Nordgreen Philosopher Watch Review: A Versatile Watch With... 11 Ways To Travel At Home That Maximize... 17 Going Away Gifts For Friend Moving Overseas. California is where I met my hubs, fell in love, and where I truly thought I was meant to be. Your photograph captures beautifully that moment of looking into the world and yet holding our own space at the same time. You are you, Kerry. 6 months ago. I have been in Bangkok since my birth. And there seems to be something objectionable in the substance of … ‘it means so much to every person…we live in a white culture’ So spot on, Katie. Do you ever have to stop and think about how to answer “Where are you from?” It’s the question that everyone seemingly asks when you meet them for the first time. (Or maybe I will move to Penang?) I haven’t watched Shanghai Kiss but it seems like a good movie to see on a lazy weekend. Moving checklist, expat life tips, bucket lists & travel agendas for USA, UK & Europe. The question itself is actually fairly innocent because people ask standard questions when they first introduce themselves to each other. We're sure you are busy so we'll make this quick: Today we need your help. Sometimes I do think a direct answer right from the get go keeps others happy and no longer curious, and you can then in turn ask them where they are from, turning the tables , Thank you so much for this spirited response, Nicole. Thanks for sharing. I identify myself as being Australian (since this is the culture I was exposed to and lived in the longest and is the place where I live permanently), but whenever I tell people (especially Asians like the one I encountered in trips to my ancestral home in Asia) that I’m Australian, they look at me like I’m nuts. Dec. 19, 2020 9:42 a.m. PT. Where are you from? They want to know what race you are. I was born in one country in Europe. - tom5, Sep 24, 2009. the UK, then again “No, what country do your parents come from?” then that’s when I have to say Hong Kong even though I’ve only been there once on holiday and not to see any relatives either. I don’t say or act in absolute. 3. I’m English, but I’m from Devon. Thanks for your reply Mabel! Thank you. 0 0. If you’re in a distant foreign country, give the name of your home country. If fate were to allow us to meet I’d love to give you a friendly hug. Reacting like you're being asked a deeply personal question is likely to alienate people, like you said, because small talk is related to a need to feel approved by someone else and maintain a positive face.